Breaking News

Constitutional Court rips criminal libel

by Daniel Nemukuyu
12 June 2014 | 2863 Views
The Constitutional Court unanimously ruled yesterday that criminal defamation must be struck off the statutes because it is not a justifiable law in a democratic society like Zimbabwe's.




The court invited Justice, Legal and Parliamentary Affairs Minister Emmerson Mnangagwa to defend the law if he so wished, before a final declaration is passed.

The Constitutional Court ruled against the law in a case brought by former Standard newspaper editor Nevanji Madanhire and reporter Nqaba Matshazi, who were being charged with criminally defaming Green Card chairperson Dr Munyaradzi Kereke.

In a unanimous ruling by the nine judges, the court presided over by Chief Justice Godfrey Chidyausiku ruled in a judgement written by Justice Barat Patel that criminalising defamation violated people's freedom of expression and muzzled the media. The court found that the right of bringing a civil suit for damages adequately protected defamed people.

The journalists, charged with breaching Section 96 of the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act, were seeking permanent stay of prosecution and repealing of the section from the statutes saying it was unconstitutional.

Madanhire and Matshazi were arrested after Dr Kereke reported to the police that they criminally defamed him in an article published in the Standard of November 6, 2011.
The article said Green Card was on the brink of collapse and failing to pay members, staff and creditors.

A Harare magistrate referred the case to the Constitutional Court after a successful application for such by the journalists.

"In short, it is not necessary to criminalise defamation statements," Chief Justice Chidyausiku said yesterday.

"Consequently, I am satisfied that the offence is not reasonably justifiable in a democratic society within the contemplation of Section 20(2) of the former Constitution.

Accordingly, it is inconsistent with the freedom of expression guaranteed by Section 20(1) of that Constitution."

Chief Justice Chidyausiku held that the journalists successfully proved their case.

"They have succeeded in demonstrating that the offence of criminal defamation is not reasonably justifiable in a democratic society on any of the grounds mentioned in Section 20(2) of the Constitution," he said.

"In the result, the Minister of Justice, Legal and Parliamentary Affairs is hereby called upon, if he so wishes, to show cause why Section 96 of the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act should not be declared to be in contravention of Section 20(1) of the former Constitution."

Chief Justice Chidyausiku directed the Chief Registrar of the Superior Courts to set the matter down for hearing at the earliest available date if Minister Mnangagwa wanted to defend the law.

If the minister wants to defend the law, he must bring new facts and legal arguments other than those already heard by the court.

It could not be established yesterday what Minister Mnangagwa makes of the ruling.

The court held that the media had an important function of disseminating information and facilitating accountability.

"Part and parcel of that role is to unearth corrupt or fraudulent activities, executive and corporate excesses and other wrongdoings that impinge upon the rights and interests of ordinary citizens," said Chief Justice Chidyausiku.

"It is inconceivable that a newspaper could perform its investigative and informative functions without defaming one person or another."

Chief Justice Chidyausiku added that the maximum penalty of two years imprisonment for criminal defamation under the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act was harsh.

"This penalty, in my view, is clearly excessive and patently disproportionate for the purpose of suppressing objectionable or opprobrious statement."

The court hailed the United Nations Commission on Human Rights castigation of criminal defamation.

The African Commission on Human and People's Rights, in Resolution 169 adopted on November 24, 2010 also condemns criminal defamation in the context of the media and calls on all member states to repeal such laws.

criminal

Source: Herald

Comments

Latest News

Angry residents burns thugs to death

by Staff Reporter | 04 May 2016 | 0 Views

National Pledge: 'Christian' outrage unjustified - The livid reactions...

by Gwinyai Mutongi | 04 May 2016 | 14 Views

Couple in court over child's death - A Harare couple on Monday appeare...

by Prosper Dembedza | 04 May 2016 | 36 Views

Man demands $400 upkeep from ex-wife - A self-employed Harare man is d...

by Tedious Manyepo | 04 May 2016 | 38 Views

ZLHR joins press in celebrating Press Freedom Day

by Stephen Jakes | 04 May 2016 | 24 Views

Zanu-PF urged to connect with the people - Ruling parties like Zanu-PF...

by Lovemore Chikova | 04 May 2016 | 31 Views

Nation crying for Mugabe's death- ZimFirst leader

by Stephen Jakes | 04 May 2016 | 109 Views

Mushore indaba deferred - again - The crunch Harare City Council speci...

by Innocent Ruwende | 04 May 2016 | 39 Views

Mudenda reprimands Kereke - The Speaker of the National Assembly Advoc...

by Zvamaida Murwira | 04 May 2016 | 66 Views

Zimbabwe minister in hospitals’ SOS - The Ministry of Health and Chi...

by Paidamoyo Chipunza | 04 May 2016 | 61 Views

National Pledge officially launched - Government yesterday defended th...

by Staff Reporters | 04 May 2016 | 59 Views

Vet officer fired for fraud

by Staff Reporter | 04 May 2016 | 77 Views

Pupils at Sinoia Primary School recite the national pledge - Pupils at...

by Staff Reporter | 04 May 2016 | 1158 Views

Any politician who cannot tolerate public criticism and ridicule is no...

by Tendai Ruben Mbofana | 03 May 2016 | 1004 Views

Kasukuwere must uphold constitutionalism - Kasukuwere must uphold con...

by E G Cross - Shadow Minister of Local Government | 03 May 2016 | 966 Views

Cervical cancer rife among sexually active Midlands girls - An increas...

by Thobekile Zhou | 03 May 2016 | 1134 Views

Fighting Corruption Is Everyone's Responsibility

by Sparkleford Masiyambiri | 03 May 2016 | 601 Views

Mnangagwa calls 'to incentivize workers' but where are the 2.2 m worke...

by Patrick Guramatanhu | 03 May 2016 | 675 Views

Christians take a stand against Dokora - Matabeleland Institute for Hu...

by Matabeleland Institute for Human Rights | 03 May 2016 | 2213 Views

Joint Statement of Democratic Political Parties - International Labour...

by Staff Reporter | 03 May 2016 | 770 Views

Entertainment

Tupac's mother, Afeni Shakur Davis, dies at 69

by Staff Reporter | 04 May 2016 | 943 Views

'Ekhweni lami' a classic value for money project

by Vusmann | 03 May 2016 | 781 Views

Macheso relishes SA tour - "We have performed in South Africa before, ...

by Tawanda Marwizi | 03 May 2016 | 943 Views

Maita crowned Miss Africa Zimbabwe - Harare beauty, Maita Kainga was c...

by Bongani Ndlovu | 02 May 2016 | 1618 Views

1ns and 2s with DJ-Sticha - Know your song Mondays

by DJ-Sticha | 02 May 2016 | 1448 Views

Interview with musician Lyfe Martinez

by Staff reporter | 01 May 2016 | 1846 Views

Busi Mhlanga flies Zimbabwe flag high in foreign lands

by Mafu Sithabile | 29 April 2016 | 6519 Views
iBlog

Apple Watch Teardown Reveals Unique Hardware And Replaceable Parts

The apple watch may not be fine jewelry, but bill detwiler cracks it open and shows you why he thinks it's a fine piece of tech. the apple watch may be beautiful on the outside, but how about on the inside? in this cracking open installment, we go in... Read More
Sergey 11 June 2015 ago

Hp Omen 15-5116tx – The Next Generation Gaming Laptop

the hp omen 15-5116tx is being targeted at the performance hungry gamers. it comes in a single variant boasting an eye-catching attractive design. the notebook offers a slim, lightweight chassis and appears like a piece of art than an actual gaming... Read More
Sergey 11 June 2015 ago