Breaking News

Constitutional Court rips criminal libel

by Daniel Nemukuyu
12 June 2014 | 2880 Views
The Constitutional Court unanimously ruled yesterday that criminal defamation must be struck off the statutes because it is not a justifiable law in a democratic society like Zimbabwe's.




The court invited Justice, Legal and Parliamentary Affairs Minister Emmerson Mnangagwa to defend the law if he so wished, before a final declaration is passed.

The Constitutional Court ruled against the law in a case brought by former Standard newspaper editor Nevanji Madanhire and reporter Nqaba Matshazi, who were being charged with criminally defaming Green Card chairperson Dr Munyaradzi Kereke.

In a unanimous ruling by the nine judges, the court presided over by Chief Justice Godfrey Chidyausiku ruled in a judgement written by Justice Barat Patel that criminalising defamation violated people's freedom of expression and muzzled the media. The court found that the right of bringing a civil suit for damages adequately protected defamed people.

The journalists, charged with breaching Section 96 of the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act, were seeking permanent stay of prosecution and repealing of the section from the statutes saying it was unconstitutional.

Madanhire and Matshazi were arrested after Dr Kereke reported to the police that they criminally defamed him in an article published in the Standard of November 6, 2011.
The article said Green Card was on the brink of collapse and failing to pay members, staff and creditors.

A Harare magistrate referred the case to the Constitutional Court after a successful application for such by the journalists.

"In short, it is not necessary to criminalise defamation statements," Chief Justice Chidyausiku said yesterday.

"Consequently, I am satisfied that the offence is not reasonably justifiable in a democratic society within the contemplation of Section 20(2) of the former Constitution.

Accordingly, it is inconsistent with the freedom of expression guaranteed by Section 20(1) of that Constitution."

Chief Justice Chidyausiku held that the journalists successfully proved their case.

"They have succeeded in demonstrating that the offence of criminal defamation is not reasonably justifiable in a democratic society on any of the grounds mentioned in Section 20(2) of the Constitution," he said.

"In the result, the Minister of Justice, Legal and Parliamentary Affairs is hereby called upon, if he so wishes, to show cause why Section 96 of the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act should not be declared to be in contravention of Section 20(1) of the former Constitution."

Chief Justice Chidyausiku directed the Chief Registrar of the Superior Courts to set the matter down for hearing at the earliest available date if Minister Mnangagwa wanted to defend the law.

If the minister wants to defend the law, he must bring new facts and legal arguments other than those already heard by the court.

It could not be established yesterday what Minister Mnangagwa makes of the ruling.

The court held that the media had an important function of disseminating information and facilitating accountability.

"Part and parcel of that role is to unearth corrupt or fraudulent activities, executive and corporate excesses and other wrongdoings that impinge upon the rights and interests of ordinary citizens," said Chief Justice Chidyausiku.

"It is inconceivable that a newspaper could perform its investigative and informative functions without defaming one person or another."

Chief Justice Chidyausiku added that the maximum penalty of two years imprisonment for criminal defamation under the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act was harsh.

"This penalty, in my view, is clearly excessive and patently disproportionate for the purpose of suppressing objectionable or opprobrious statement."

The court hailed the United Nations Commission on Human Rights castigation of criminal defamation.

The African Commission on Human and People's Rights, in Resolution 169 adopted on November 24, 2010 also condemns criminal defamation in the context of the media and calls on all member states to repeal such laws.

criminal

Source: Herald

Comments

Latest News

So what's next for Dynamos? - It is with very sad to be a Dynamos play...

by Lord Morris Kakunguwo, | 29 May 2016 | 1039 Views

Watch: 'I Don't Regret What I Did to Mugabe' - I Don't Regret What I D...

by Staff Reporter | 29 May 2016 | 2935 Views

Zanu PF is imploding and Manheru sings a mournful 'Zanu yedu tinoida' ...

by Patrick Guramatunhu | 29 May 2016 | 1255 Views

Mazibisa in Forbes Africa's 30 under 30 Class of 2016 - Nkosana Mazibi...

by Staff reporter | 29 May 2016 | 1371 Views

Thief caught in the act undressed - THIS thug will think twice before ...

by Staff Reporter | 29 May 2016 | 3216 Views

Foreigners flee as looting starts in SA

by Staff Reporter | 29 May 2016 | 4555 Views

Dagga worth R500 000 recovered

by Staff Reporter | 29 May 2016 | 1108 Views

Mujuru under siege - SCORES of alleged Zimbabwe People First (ZimPF) s...

by Staff reporter | 29 May 2016 | 3175 Views

Mnangangwa's ally escapes death - CONTROVERSIAL former Zanu-PF central...

by Staf reporter | 29 May 2016 | 3278 Views

Bosso sink fading Dembare in thriller

by Ishemunyoro Chingwere | 29 May 2016 | 1527 Views

Woman attacks MDC-T for abuse of dead hubby - THE widow of human right...

by Roberta Katunga | 29 May 2016 | 1339 Views

Man stones wife to death - IN a typical Sharia law application, a Gwan...

by Lynnia Ndlovu | 29 May 2016 | 1700 Views

Murder victims family turns down compensation - THE family of three ch...

by Walter Mswazie | 29 May 2016 | 1561 Views

Townsend school bus 'stolen' - DARING robbers last Monday pounced on T...

by Vusumuzi Dube | 29 May 2016 | 1850 Views

Civil servants to sign for payslip - CIVIL servants are now required t...

by Staff reporter | 29 May 2016 | 1584 Views

New town to be built outside Bulawayo - A NEW town is set to be establ...

by Vusumuzi Dube | 29 May 2016 | 3681 Views

Tsvangirai fails to turn up, MDC-T demonstration fails to hit target -...

by Dumisani Sibanda | 29 May 2016 | 1335 Views

Fallen bigwigs appeal to Zanu-PF - SEVERAL senior politicians suspende...

by Staff reporter | 29 May 2016 | 1146 Views

Man rapes lover, forces friend to rape her too while he watches - IN a...

by Tatenda Gapare | 29 May 2016 | 1586 Views

Bosso 90 take on Bantu in explosive derby - TWO former Highlanders pla...

by Raymond Jaravaza | 29 May 2016 | 1282 Views

'We don't get powers from Nigeria,' says Prophet Magaya - FOLLOWING Pr...

by Brian Chitemba | 29 May 2016 | 1255 Views

Harare should learn a thing or two from Bulawayo - Bulawayo City Counc...

by Harmony Agere | 29 May 2016 | 1104 Views

Little Bishop's daughter in gay storm - RETIRED Bishop Desmond Tutu's ...

by Staff reporter | 29 May 2016 | 1200 Views

'I've been invited to Heaven ... again' - Christians will tell you the...

by Wendy Nyakurerwa | 29 May 2016 | 1591 Views

Ghost civil servants flushed out - CIVIL servants are now required to ...

by Lincoln Towindo | 29 May 2016 | 1173 Views

Motorists recount their nightmares with ZRP - Questions sent to Asst C...

by Staff reporter | 29 May 2016 | 1222 Views

Entertainment

Hosiah Chipanga fights in Tuku's corner - Outspoken and talented sungu...

by Staff reporter | 29 May 2016 | 1727 Views

Mtukudzi loses his lustre - The country's harsh economic situation has...

by Staff reporter | 29 May 2016 | 1894 Views

Zim kwaito stars make waves in UK - "We have never been good at follow...

by Showbiz Reporter | 28 May 2016 | 1289 Views

Sandy, Khuliyo show tickets selling like hotcakes - THE Sandra Ndebele...

by Bongani Ndlovu | 26 May 2016 | 2349 Views