Breaking News

Constitutional Court rips criminal libel

by Daniel Nemukuyu
13 June 2014 | 2782 Views
The Constitutional Court unanimously ruled yesterday that criminal defamation must be struck off the statutes because it is not a justifiable law in a democratic society like Zimbabwe's.

The court invited Justice, Legal and Parliamentary Affairs Minister Emmerson Mnangagwa to defend the law if he so wished, before a final declaration is passed.

The Constitutional Court ruled against the law in a case brought by former Standard newspaper editor Nevanji Madanhire and reporter Nqaba Matshazi, who were being charged with criminally defaming Green Card chairperson Dr Munyaradzi Kereke.

In a unanimous ruling by the nine judges, the court presided over by Chief Justice Godfrey Chidyausiku ruled in a judgement written by Justice Barat Patel that criminalising defamation violated people's freedom of expression and muzzled the media. The court found that the right of bringing a civil suit for damages adequately protected defamed people.

The journalists, charged with breaching Section 96 of the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act, were seeking permanent stay of prosecution and repealing of the section from the statutes saying it was unconstitutional.

Madanhire and Matshazi were arrested after Dr Kereke reported to the police that they criminally defamed him in an article published in the Standard of November 6, 2011.
The article said Green Card was on the brink of collapse and failing to pay members, staff and creditors.

A Harare magistrate referred the case to the Constitutional Court after a successful application for such by the journalists.

"In short, it is not necessary to criminalise defamation statements," Chief Justice Chidyausiku said yesterday.

"Consequently, I am satisfied that the offence is not reasonably justifiable in a democratic society within the contemplation of Section 20(2) of the former Constitution.

Accordingly, it is inconsistent with the freedom of expression guaranteed by Section 20(1) of that Constitution."

Chief Justice Chidyausiku held that the journalists successfully proved their case.

"They have succeeded in demonstrating that the offence of criminal defamation is not reasonably justifiable in a democratic society on any of the grounds mentioned in Section 20(2) of the Constitution," he said.

"In the result, the Minister of Justice, Legal and Parliamentary Affairs is hereby called upon, if he so wishes, to show cause why Section 96 of the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act should not be declared to be in contravention of Section 20(1) of the former Constitution."

Chief Justice Chidyausiku directed the Chief Registrar of the Superior Courts to set the matter down for hearing at the earliest available date if Minister Mnangagwa wanted to defend the law.

If the minister wants to defend the law, he must bring new facts and legal arguments other than those already heard by the court.

It could not be established yesterday what Minister Mnangagwa makes of the ruling.

The court held that the media had an important function of disseminating information and facilitating accountability.

"Part and parcel of that role is to unearth corrupt or fraudulent activities, executive and corporate excesses and other wrongdoings that impinge upon the rights and interests of ordinary citizens," said Chief Justice Chidyausiku.

"It is inconceivable that a newspaper could perform its investigative and informative functions without defaming one person or another."

Chief Justice Chidyausiku added that the maximum penalty of two years imprisonment for criminal defamation under the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act was harsh.

"This penalty, in my view, is clearly excessive and patently disproportionate for the purpose of suppressing objectionable or opprobrious statement."




The court hailed the United Nations Commission on Human Rights castigation of criminal defamation.

The African Commission on Human and People's Rights, in Resolution 169 adopted on November 24, 2010 also condemns criminal defamation in the context of the media and calls on all member states to repeal such laws.

criminal

Source: Herald

Does Prophet Magaya's anointing oil work?

Yes
16.94%
No
70.82%
Spiritual matters
12.24%
425

Comments

News Updates

Email:

Latest News

FlyAfrica mulls special fare for school children - Local budget airlin...

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 82 Views

Mugabe son in-law in no show - President Robert Mugabe's son in law Si...

by Staff Reporter | 02 March 2015 | 722 Views

Women stabs hubby with 3 kitchen knives, killing him in the process - ...

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 1833 Views

All Zimbabweans are equal regardless of race, colour or creed - Zim...

by Obert Chaurura Gutu | 02 March 2015 | 802 Views

Unpacking Mugabe's own lack of confidence in his 'leadership' abilitie...

by Fbr Mthokozisi Ndiweni | 02 March 2015 | 1022 Views

MDC-United unstoppable, Zimbabweans pin hopes on teamwork - The on cou...

by Kurauone Chihwayi | 02 March 2015 | 1096 Views

Mugabe's imprisonment threat enough to scar the cowardly Mutasa! - Mug...

by Wilbert Mukori | 02 March 2015 | 1861 Views

Gushungo Dairy to start ice cream and chocolate production - Grace Mug...

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 835 Views

Bus accident 6 dead, 39 injured - Six people died while 39 were injur...

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 2125 Views

Mugabe told to 'stop making laughable public statements' - Former Zanu...

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 3515 Views

Mujuru and her allies will rot in jail, says Mugabe - In an ominous bi...

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 2820 Views

'I'm not afraid of Mugabe' - Former Zanu-PF spokesperson Rugare Gumbo ...

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 3608 Views

Zimbabwean youngster signs 2 year contract with Ipswich - A highly ra...

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 3569 Views

Chiyangwa appears to have patched things with wife Elizabeth

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 5734 Views

Welshman Ncube, Tendai Biti in futile endeavour

by chronicle editorial | 02 March 2015 | 4751 Views

Mutasa, the Chinhoyi diesel discovery illusionary badly miscalculated ...

by Suitable Kajau | 02 March 2015 | 3808 Views

The inevitable demise of opposition politics in Zimbabwe - The post 20...

by Prince Khumbulani Malinga | 02 March 2015 | 1312 Views

Wanted person - Picture - Police are looking for a man wanted in con...

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 5759 Views

Chaos at Zinasu meeting - A ZIMBABWE National Students Union (ZINASU) ...

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 1452 Views

Supersport deal delays Zimbabwe PSL kick-off - SOCCER fans would have ...

by Grace Chingoma | 02 March 2015 | 2000 Views

Mugabe eyesight problems worsen - PRESIDENT Robert Mugabe's eyesight p...

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 5297 Views

Mnangagwa was first class freedom fighter but State President, no! - W...

by Patrick Guramatunhu | 02 March 2015 | 3206 Views

World Bank to disburse funds to Zimbabwe this month - The World Bank w...

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 2178 Views

'Opposition party members' children denied access to educational assis...

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 962 Views

'We don't regret supporting Zanu-PF,' says Charumbira - Zimbabwe Chief...

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 1084 Views

Mphoko unfit to lead National Healing and Reconciliation - Heal Zimbab...

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 857 Views

'I once confronted Mugabe,' says Mnangagwa - Vice President Emmerson M...

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 4262 Views

Grace jumped gun on Mujuru, says Mugabe - President Robert Mugabe has ...

by Staff reporter | 02 March 2015 | 4799 Views

Entertainment

DStv annual price increase effective 1 April 2015 - MultiChoice Afric...

by Mafu Sithabile | 02 March 2015 | 1112 Views

Popular Zim dancehall chanter arrested for fraud

by Liberty Dube | 27 February 2015 | 3411 Views

Group pens song for Mugabe - A 7-member group from Acturus has release...

by Staff reporter | 21 February 2015 | 1884 Views

Mathias Mhere saga takes new twist - Gift Mahlupeka, who allegedly che...

by Staff reporter | 20 February 2015 | 10384 Views

Mlambos Express Band flies Matabeleland Flag - Mlambos Express Band po...

by Entertainment Reporter | 20 February 2015 | 3327 Views

Will Smith's marriage is pretty much dead - For the past 18 years, Wil...

by BlackAmericaWeb | 19 February 2015 | 7059 Views
iBlog

Those Behind Tb Joshua Watch Photo Proof!

when this couple (dave and angie) were indicted of being the masterminds behind tb joshua watch, the blog admins refuted it and denied any sort of connections with the couple, but that’s not what the facts portray as precisely every single one ... Read More
pointblank 13 July 2014 ago

Rules Or Relationship

The dog does not need a lead to go for a walk. its owner can just speak a word and the dog responds. now, we are not comparing ourselves to dogs, we are comparing performance-based christian living to relationship-based christian living. big, big ... Read More
LindaDiokpa 30 December 2014 ago