Breaking News

MDC-T's Juice offers little

by Tafadzwa Musarara
11 February 2013 | 2932 Views
After spending three years in government without its own party economic blue print but only deploying its energy towards demonising Zanu-PF's indigenisation policy, MDC-T has exposed its policy dysfunction with the launch of a vacuous economic policy.

The economic blueprint, Jobs, Upliftment, Investment, Capital and the Environment (Juice), authored by Eddie Cross and UK-based consultant Lance Mambondiani, is a poor attempt to duplicate current government economic policies under the guise of new terminology.

The entire document is replete with inaccuracies and outright plagiarism of other current economic blueprints, especially the government's Medium Term Plan (MTP).
 
First and foremost, it is difficult to believe MDC-T's commitment to deliver on its economic policy which is based on investment devoid of government intervention. In a recent piece titled "My Crystal Ball", Cross, said: "The MD-TC would announce a small government – a Cabinet of 20 ministers with 18 ministries.

The President and Cabinet would be sworn in and would immediately begin a complete overhaul of the State administration. Marange diamond fields would be nationalised and all existing operators expelled."

Did I hear nationalisation here?

The entire premise of the blueprint is that of jobs. Tsvangirai makes this very clear in the foreword to the document. It is the be-all and end-all. He argues that what Zimbabweans need are jobs, hence his economic plan is to avail jobs to all Zimbabweans.

It is through jobs that Zimbabweans will be empowered, he argues.

This argument is fundamentally flawed.

The blueprint is anti-indigenisation and empowerment, referring to this programme as looting and asset stripping. It asserts that current empowerment policies are meant to enrich the elite and politically-connected without proffering any evidence to that end.

Current empowerment transactions expose this fallacy and contradict this assertion as there is no evidence that a few elite have benefited for these deals.

It has mainly been management, employee share ownership schemes, community share ownership trusts as well as the National Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment Board (Nieeb) that have been the beneficiaries of these schemes.

There is little or no evidence of capital flight in response to indigenisation of those firms already invested in Zimbabwe.

Indigenisation transactions such as promulgated by ZIMPLATS have been by way of vendor financing, thus offering value to prior investments.

Strangely, one of the objectives of Juice is "restructuring the ownership and control of the economy through a broad-based economic empowerment programme" which is an acknowledgement of the need for indigenous participation in the economy through ownership of the means of production.

But Juice then goes on to claim that this will be achieved through training, supporting SME's, formalisation of the informal sector, job placements and so on.

This is totally absurd as ownership and control can only be achieved through the vehicle of capital.

The MDC-T must realise that local ownership of capital is a global phenomenon irrespective of which country one is in.

One can argue about thresholds but not the principle. Any other careless option will leave countries at the mercy of foreign capital and ultimately foreign political influence.

In the USA, Dubai Ports had won the right to manage huge American ports, but this attracted the ire of locals who felt that they were giving up their sovereignty and security to foreigners. The indigenous people won.

Juice is content on having local Zimbabweans as employees of foreign multinationals with limited participation in ownership.

Juice acknowledges that one of the key drivers of economic growth is increased and sustainable agricultural production.

However, the conduct of the MDC-T in government and the minister of Finance in particular displays a scant regard to this notion.

In 2012, Tendai Biti promised that he would provide for $20 million towards winter wheat farming. To date, no dime has come out of Treasury.

Funding for inputs have been low and erratic and at times reaching the beneficiaries late to be effective.

The policy is very suspect on the land reform beneficiaries and the fate of former white commercial farmers. It does not address the irreversibility of the land reform and future ownership patterns.

Any future agricultural policy in Zimbabwe must focus on how to underpin and consolidate the agrarian reform through land tenure and creating a sustainable agricultural sector through access to funding and extension services.

According to the MDC-T's own research, formal employment peaked at 1,35 million in 1998 from about one million in 1980 under a Zanu-PF government then dropping to just under one million in 2010, close to the 1980 levels.

It acknowledges the massive growth of the informal sector in the last 20 years which accounts for absorption of jobs lost in the formal sector and population differentials between 1980 and 2010.

There hasn't been major movement in formal employment numbers in the 30 years since independence on a net basis. The informal sector has absorbed additional entrants in the employment market.

Juice contains serious inaccuracies in the employment numbers especially in the agricultural sector claiming only 20 000 people were employed in the agricultural sector in 2008 but also asserts that 150 000 were employed in this sector in 2010.

There is no explanation of this sudden leap in numbers.

Any future economic policy by any political party must pay close attention to sustainable job creation through growing the economy and encouraging capital formation by way of cultivating local savings and foreign direct investiment (FDI).

Jobs allow new entrants into the money economy and help to expand the local market.

The party claims that it will create one million jobs between 2013 and 2018 based on an annual economic growth rate of eight percent. The figure is unreal, as it cannot be achieved in such a short space of time whilst the leading Western economies' employment figures are heading south.

This is fuzzy mathematics considering our current GDP numbers.

The numbers become even fuzzier when one considers its projection of targeted FDI of 30 percent of annual GDP. It is difficult to see how these jobs will be created on such a low base and single digit GDP growth numbers unless they are extremely low-paying jobs in agriculture.

This assertion is not backed by the numbers. The numbers don't add up especially considering the high targeted FDI which is not reflected in GDP and the GDP growth rate.

On road infrastructure, it claims that focus will be on the modernisation and dualisation of Beitbridge-Chirundu, Plumtree-Mutare and Harare-Nyamapanda highways.

These projects are already in motion with construction work already at an advanced stage on the Plumtree-Mutare Highway and feasibility studies being finalised on the Beitbridge-Harare Highway as part of the Chirundu corridor.

There is very little in terms of empirical evidence to bolster the policy conclusions.




The Juice document is juicy-dry and cannot give the indigenes the economic syrup required.

------------------------
*Tafadzwa Musarara is the chairperson of Resources Exploitation Watch 


Juice MDC-T


Disclaimer:
All articles and letters published on Bulawayo24 have been independently written by members of Bulawayo24's community. The views of users published on Bulawayo24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Bulawayo24. Bulawayo24 editors also reserve the right to edit or delete any and all comments received.

Source: dailynews

Should airtime and street vendors pay the $1 a day State levy?

Yes
11.66%
No
81.99%
Desperation
6.34%
883

Comments

News Updates

Email:

Latest News

MLF's Magagula and Mugabe can never be Leaders of a Diverse Country - ...

by Ryton Dzimiri | 01 September 2014 | 571 Views

Jonathan Moyo, Obert Mpofu eye Zanu PF chairmanship - Zanu PF politbur...

by Staff Reporter | 01 September 2014 | 687 Views

China was Mugabe's last chance to get ZimAsset funding he got nothing ...

by Wilbert Mukori, Secretary General Zimbabwe Social Democrats | 01 September 2014 | 784 Views

Highlanders, Dynamos clash in TM-Pick'n'Pay challenge - A new sponsor ...

by Staff Reporter | 01 September 2014 | 889 Views

Two more toll gates open

by Staff Reporter | 01 September 2014 | 2045 Views

'I am looking for Sidanile and Nkosilathi Nyathi' - WhatsApp update - ...

by Gervasio Tshuma | 01 September 2014 | 921 Views

Shame on you! - We are living on precious time. The young Zimbabwean ...

by Tafadzwa Murwisi | 01 September 2014 | 2470 Views

Six injured in road accident - Pictures - Six people were reportedly i...

by Staff reporter | 01 September 2014 | 3382 Views

Song on MDC-T's call for donations - Video - Song on MDC-T's call for ...

by Youtube | 01 September 2014 | 1424 Views

'New Zimbabwe' by 2018 - The year is 2018 and the spotlight is on a sm...

by Obert Gutu | 01 September 2014 | 2556 Views

Mugabe raps Zanu-PF Harare leadership - President Robert Mugabe has sl...

by Staff reporter | 01 September 2014 | 1638 Views

Australia's shock one-day defeat to Zimbabwe raise alarm bells - Melbo...

by Reuters | 01 September 2014 | 1506 Views

Mthwakazi does not need sympathy from Zimbabweans - Editor,The recentl...

by David Magagula | 01 September 2014 | 1874 Views

Zimbabwe Chief Justice's offices burgled - Unknown people broke into C...

by Staff reporter | 01 September 2014 | 1691 Views

'I'm in control,' says Mugabe - President Robert Mugabe has stamped au...

by Staff reporter | 01 September 2014 | 4128 Views

'Mugabe's octopus grip on power has impoverished Zimbabwe' - MDC-T lea...

by Staff reporter | 01 September 2014 | 1339 Views

Avenging spirit kills 20 family members in 2 years

by Danisa Masuku | 01 September 2014 | 4699 Views

Sister attempts to bed brother

by Chido Macherenje | 01 September 2014 | 5338 Views

Marriage collapses as uncle sends married niece explicit pictures

by Staff reporter | 01 September 2014 | 5680 Views

Brutal attack over missing foreskins - AN action-packed drama reported...

by Staff reporter | 01 September 2014 | 3230 Views

Man displays 'girlfriend's' picture in matrimonial bedroom - A MADLY i...

by Staff reporter | 01 September 2014 | 3991 Views

Drama as man breaks woman's leg for dancing with another man - HELL ha...

by Michael Magoronga | 01 September 2014 | 2961 Views

Haulage truck accident survivors speak out - TWO passengers who surviv...

by Staff Reporter | 01 September 2014 | 2478 Views

Meet the new Miss Gweru

by Sukoluhle Ndlovu | 01 September 2014 | 1797 Views

Stillborn baby goes missing from hospital - A STILLBORN baby reportedl...

by Danisa Masuku | 01 September 2014 | 1726 Views

Uncle rapes pregnant new bride - INSTEAD of ensuring her niece's safet...

by Michael Magoronga | 01 September 2014 | 3503 Views

'Ngidinga izihlobo zakithi' - jhb south Africa 2014-08-22 19:13:38Mina...

by Thabani Dlamini | 01 September 2014 | 1743 Views

Mugabe returns from China with a bag of secretive agreements

by Staff reporter | 01 September 2014 | 2712 Views

Gono mysteriously travelled to US while under US travel embargo

by Staff reporter | 01 September 2014 | 3883 Views

Rapist claims he owns teen victim's privates

by Auxilia Katongomara | 01 September 2014 | 2579 Views

Entertainment

ZBC receives TV programmes from South Korea - The Korean Ambassador to...

by Staff Reporter | 29 August 2014 | 2200 Views

Roki cancels SA show

by Sophia Chese | 29 August 2014 | 1954 Views

Zimbabwe Got Talent on the cards - CHINESE Federation of Zimbabwe (CFZ...

by Staff reporter | 28 August 2014 | 1662 Views

Tuku to Deliver Inaugural Hugh Masekela Lecture

by Staff Reporter | 28 August 2014 | 2166 Views

Controversy over Bev's album - Newly-appointed Msasa Bricks Ambassador...

by Staff reporter | 27 August 2014 | 2614 Views

Viewers slam 'sub-standard' ZBCtv program - VARIOUS ZBCtv viewers have...

by Staff reporter | 27 August 2014 | 2553 Views

John Legend cancels Zimbabwe show

by Showbiz Reporter | 27 August 2014 | 4867 Views

Macheso's yet to be released album sold on Harare streets - Pirates ha...

by Staff reporter | 26 August 2014 | 3865 Views