Breaking News

Biti critisized for disclosing the Government account balance

by Staff Reporter
01 February 2013 | 3657 Views
FINANCE Minister Tendai Biti has come under fire for disclosing the Government account balance amid calls for the principals to reprimand him.

Minister Biti on Tuesday told journalists that the Treasury account was left with US$217 after paying civil servants salaries about a fortnight ago.

The finance minister has since made a U-turn claiming that journalists had quoted him out of context.

He told the international media that he was only dramatising Zimbabwe’s bankruptcy.
"You journalists are mischievous and malicious - the point I was making was that the Zimbabwean Government doesn’t have the funds to finance the election, to finance the referendum," Biti told the BBC.

"To dramatise the point, I simply made a passing reference metaphorically that when we paid civil servants last week on Thursday, we were left with US$217, but the following day we had US$30 million in our account."

However, observers yesterday condemned Minister Biti for his utterances.
"I think it is wrong for a minister of Government who swore to secrecy and upholding the Constitution to be the source of information which undermines the State and exposes the nation," said Midlands State University Dean of Social Sciences Mr Christopher Gwatidzo.

"That disclosure creates alarm and despondency. There has been a serious breach of confidentiality even if it was the case which I dont believe anyway. Obviously one would think there is a sinister political agenda becaue he is a lawyer who knows he is deliberately breaching the law. He is someone who decided to deliberately enter the red robbot.

"I hope the leaders in Government will take action against such behaviour because this is gross irresponsibility. This is a case that warrants action from the Head of State and the Prime Minister."
Mr Gwatidzo said Minister Biti’s disclosure justifies calls for the elections to get rid of the coalition Government.

University of Zimbabwe lecturer in the Department of International Relations Dr Charity Manyeruke weighed in saying Minister Biti had jumped the gun.

"Our Finance Minister has to understand the structures of Government and their purposes. Once he knows that he will be able to know there are committees where such interim disclosures can be made, for instance in internal meetings in the ministry, in Cabinet and Parliament.

"The leadership in Government should look at this case seriously and take appropriate action. The minister should understand that he took the oath. He cannot carelessly disclose information that is prejudicial to the State," said Dr Manyeruke.

Lawyer Mr Terrence Hussein of Ranchhod and Hussein law firm said Minister Biti’s disclosure was morally wrong.

"I think legally, I wouldn’t find anything faulty with him. However, i think it is morally and ethically wrong to go around brandishing such information. It is like a bank disclosing its figures carelessly which may reduce bankers’ confidence in the bank. It is the same case with this disclosure. If one says that, they won’t be helping the country in any way but are instead undermining it.

"I think it is important for Principals and Cabinet to set parameters for ministers to know which information to disclose. As damage control, there is need for leaders to verify the balance in the Government account for them to set the record straight," said Mr Hussein.

However, former Attorney General Mr Andrew Chigovera said there was nothing wrong with Minister Biti disclosing the figures.




"He is the Minister of Finance who knows what is in the account and if there are people doubting what he said they should prove him wrong. I don’t understand why there is this hullabaloo.

"Unless people are saying he shouldn’t have disclosed the figures to the public who have a right to know such information anyway," said Mr Chigovera.


account

Source: Zimpapers

Should airtime and street vendors pay the $1 a day State levy?

Yes
11.6%
No
82.09%
Desperation
6.31%
871

Comments

News Updates

Email:

Latest News

Avenging spirit kills 20 family members in 2 years

by Danisa Masuku | 01 September 2014 | 745 Views

Sister attempts to bed brother

by Chido Macherenje | 01 September 2014 | 1026 Views

Marriage collapses as uncle sends married niece explicit pictures

by Staff reporter | 01 September 2014 | 1320 Views

Brutal attack over missing foreskins - AN action-packed drama reported...

by Staff reporter | 01 September 2014 | 836 Views

Man displays 'girlfriend's' picture in matrimonial bedroom - A MADLY i...

by Staff reporter | 01 September 2014 | 1459 Views

Ways and means to improve pass rate in national exams - It is infamous...

by Peacemaker Zano | 01 September 2014 | 428 Views

Drama as man breaks woman's leg for dancing with another man - HELL ha...

by Michael Magoronga | 01 September 2014 | 1223 Views

Haulage truck accident survivors speak out - TWO passengers who surviv...

by Staff Reporter | 01 September 2014 | 906 Views

Meet the new Miss Gweru

by Sukoluhle Ndlovu | 01 September 2014 | 722 Views

Stillborn baby goes missing from hospital - A STILLBORN baby reportedl...

by Danisa Masuku | 01 September 2014 | 756 Views

Uncle rapes pregnant new bride - INSTEAD of ensuring her niece's safet...

by Michael Magoronga | 01 September 2014 | 1403 Views

'Ngidinga izihlobo zakithi' - jhb south Africa 2014-08-22 19:13:38Mina...

by Thabani Dlamini | 01 September 2014 | 844 Views

Mugabe returns from China with a bag of secretive agreements

by Staff reporter | 01 September 2014 | 1416 Views

Gono mysteriously travelled to US while under US travel embargo

by Staff reporter | 01 September 2014 | 1841 Views

Rapist claims he owns teen victim's privates

by Auxilia Katongomara | 01 September 2014 | 1321 Views

Robert Mugabe, a victim of Zanu-PF lies

by Staff reporter | 01 September 2014 | 1077 Views

Man defrauds Ecocash agents

by Staff Reporter | 01 September 2014 | 1285 Views

San language lobbyist Banini Moyo dies - SAN language lobbyist Moffatt...

by Staff Reporter | 01 September 2014 | 874 Views

Indian cyclist on world tour to raise awareness on Aids arrives in Zimbabwe

by Staff Reporter | 01 September 2014 | 621 Views

Woman claims maintenance from two men for upkeep of daughter

by Staff Reporter | 01 September 2014 | 1072 Views

Armed robbers burn minister's truck to a shell - Three armed robbers d...

by Staff Reporter | 01 September 2014 | 1301 Views

MDC-T MP wanted by police for bashing senior party official

by Staff Reporter | 01 September 2014 | 993 Views

John Nkomo's ex-bodyguard convicted of attempted murder - A FORMER bod...

by Staff Reporter | 01 September 2014 | 772 Views

Security guard gets 6 years behind bars for stealing

by Mashudu Netsianda | 01 September 2014 | 771 Views

Minister's powers to be whittled down - The powers of Minister of Loc...

by Staff Reporter | 01 September 2014 | 1282 Views

Zimbabwe dismisses constitutional crisis claim

by Staff Reporter | 01 September 2014 | 582 Views

SA turns truckers away over Ebola - South African immigration officers...

by Staff Reporter | 01 September 2014 | 857 Views

Biti, Mangoma fallout

by The Standard | 01 September 2014 | 1467 Views

Biti threatens to recall Mugabe

by Staff Reporter | 01 September 2014 | 1840 Views

Zanu-PF MP offends Mugabe loyalists - IT never rains but pours for Har...

by Staff reporter | 01 September 2014 | 1038 Views

Entertainment

ZBC receives TV programmes from South Korea - The Korean Ambassador to...

by Staff Reporter | 29 August 2014 | 2085 Views

Roki cancels SA show

by Sophia Chese | 29 August 2014 | 1832 Views

Zimbabwe Got Talent on the cards - CHINESE Federation of Zimbabwe (CFZ...

by Staff reporter | 28 August 2014 | 1617 Views

Tuku to Deliver Inaugural Hugh Masekela Lecture

by Staff Reporter | 28 August 2014 | 2078 Views

Controversy over Bev's album - Newly-appointed Msasa Bricks Ambassador...

by Staff reporter | 27 August 2014 | 2461 Views

Viewers slam 'sub-standard' ZBCtv program - VARIOUS ZBCtv viewers have...

by Staff reporter | 27 August 2014 | 2486 Views

John Legend cancels Zimbabwe show

by Showbiz Reporter | 27 August 2014 | 4777 Views

Macheso's yet to be released album sold on Harare streets - Pirates ha...

by Staff reporter | 26 August 2014 | 3727 Views